club search
06 January 2009   










Magill On Monday - contributed by Daniel Magill

As far as the England manager's post goes it would appear that a foreign manager or Terry Venables is the only choice we have. If that is true, and I would like to think that it's not, then Venables should be given the job quicker than you can say "Where's my passport, I'm off for a highly paid jaunt in England!"

Yes, you can add my name to the long list who think having a foreign manager of the England football team would be the worst idea since one FA bright spark thought to himself, "that Graham Taylor, he'd make a fantastic international manager."

I don't feel this way solely because it would be going against great tradition, or because victory wouldn't be as sweet under a foreigner. No, I feel like this because I suspect victory would be far less likely under a foreign coach.

Let's take a look at the evidence. Firstly, for the last 10 years or so there had been a general opinion within this country that the FA was full of old men who once had a passion for the sport, but whose lack of business know-how and passing years, was a source of great embarrassment for English football. Fair point. Responding to this criticism, a young man with proven business record and a zest for football was installed as the FA's new chief executive last year. No problem there, until of course Mr Crozier meets with his first real test. As soon as Crozier came under a little pressure last week, what was the first line of criticism to be aimed at him? "He's Scottish." "He doesn't care about England." "He knows nothing of our tradition."

How can Crozier possibly respond to such criticism? Yes he is Scottish, yes he does probably care more about Scotland and it's traditions than England. Seemingly for this reason alone people have been demanding Crozier's resignation. Why ever should it be any different for a foreign manager when he hits his first bad patch? And to those who say that they don't care about his nationality but want him out because of his lack of footballing experience, take a look at George Graham at Spurs. Here is the most successful and experienced English manager in recent years, yet seemingly the majority of Spurs fans want to see the back of him because he was once an Arsenal man and he knows little or nothing about Spurs' traditions. Would a Scottish or, dare I say it, German manager of the England team meet with such unfair criticism? Of course he would. Would it affect his ability to handle the job? Of course it would.

No, if Terry Venables is the only English man willing to take on the job then let him have it, despite his disappointing record at Euro 96. (Well would you call two wins and three draws on home soil, a roaring success?)

Finally this week, did you hear the story about the football league scout who asked his club secretary to book him a flight to Kristiansand. Unfortunately there was some confusion and he ended up at Kristianstad in Sweden. He said, "I only realised when I saw a big blue and gold flag. It looked like Ikea and I had no money."

Thankfully the club managed to wire some cash over to the stranded scout, and he returned safely with a stylish new sofa bed, a new unit for his office and a handy little box for his socks!

Seriously though it set me to thinking. Maybe football is strewn with such catastrophic misunderstandings. I'm only guessing but I wonder if Walter Smith was mis-heard over the summer, when keen to commission a portrait of the famous Goodison park, he rang his old chum Bryan Robson at Middlesborough and asked him to send over an experienced pitch artist. It would certainly explain a lot!

E-mail me with any comments or views: dmabfc@aol.com.